You joined us as we relived the magic of McKinley High by watching all six seasons of Glee… and now we’re keeping the music going. This time, we’re stepping outside the choir room and diving into some of the most iconic musicals ever. Think: Rocky Horror Picture Show. Grease. Hairspray. West Side Story. Moulin Rouge. Wicked. And of course, High School Musical. But we’re not stopping there - we’ll also celebrate unforgettable musical TV projects like Smash, Nashville, Crazy Ex-Girlfriend… plus those surprise musical episodes of shows you already love, like Grey’s Anatomy, Riverdale, and The Flash. We’ll be joined by cast members, musicians, and special guests to spill behind-the-scenes stories … plus the writers, creators, and friends who brought these projects to life. And don’t worry, we’ll still have plenty of Glee surprises along the way. If you’re a fan of musicals - on the big screen, on TV, or anywhere in between - join us every week as we break down the songs, the stories, and the magic that made us all fall in love with musicals in the first place.
Before Glee, there was American Dreams on NBC. Jenna and Vanessa Lengies, filling in for Kevin, are taking it back to the early 2000s to recap the pilot episode of the nostalgic TV series 'American Dreams,' starring Sugar Motta herself! Vanessa shares behind-the-scenes stories from her time on the show, from her audition experience at 15, to her relationship with her co-star and next-door neighbor, Brittany Snow, and a scene she wishes she could have said no to. Plus, the music, the huge guest stars, including the one who made her so nervous she hid under a blanket, and spending her off-hours at the under-21 hotspot where all the biggest celeb teens, like Hillary Duff and Lindsay Lohan, were hanging out!! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
09/02/2026 • 53:34
What actually makes something a “comfort” watch? This week, Jenna & Kevin break down the shows and movies they find themselves coming back to over and over ... and their picks are way less predictable than you might expect. From dark dramas and action blockbusters to nostalgic rewatches that help them unwind, they talk about why familiarity just feels good, how comfort viewing shifts with different phases of life, and why sometimes the least “cozy” choices end up being the most comforting.For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
05/02/2026 • 20:44
Introducing Tartie Takes! Where Jenna & Kevin dive into pop culture topics they can’t stop thinking about.Inspired by the online response to Heated Rivalry, Jenna & Kevin reflect on how fandom has evolved and how much of it echoes their Glee days. From Taylor Swift to Bridgerton, they explore the joy, connection, and complexity of being a fan today.For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
02/02/2026 • 34:06
Jenna & Kevin are joined by Johnathon Schaech, who played Jimmy in That Thing You Do!, to talk about the audition that changed his life! From dressing the part, singing the iconic “I quit” line, and walking out. He shares what it was like working with Tom Hanks and Liv Tyler, becoming a real band on set, and how a simple acting instinct helped shape the movie. Plus, why the film’s legacy still lives on today, even inspiring HAIM’s album I Quit.For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
29/01/2026 • 30:30
Jenna & Kevin revisit what they believe is a perfect movie, Tom Hanks’ directorial and writing debut, That Thing You Do! They share their own stories of meeting Tom Hanks (and why you SHOULD meet your heroes), including the moment when Tom & Rita told Lea Michele she was “robbed” at the Golden Globes. Plus, they gush over the cast, the music, Liv Tyler’s performance, develop a crush on Tom Everett Scott, and debate why this movie has never become a stage musical. For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
26/01/2026 • 38:07
Kevin finally went to see Just In Time with Jonathan Groff and bumped into Matthew Morrison! Plus, Kevin shares the behind-the-scenes chaos of Spelling Bee’s real-life Traitors game, and Jenna & Kevin debate which Glee cast members they’d want to sit next to (and avoid) on a 10-hour flight.For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
22/01/2026 • 21:17
No need to ‘wait for it’ ... Jenna and Kevin are ‘not throwin away’ their shot and finally reviewing one of the most popular Broadway musicals of all time - Hamilton! They share their memories of watching it live in person (Jenna saw the original cast) and of its streaming debut during the pandemic. Jenna also reveals the personal reason why watching the pro shot version left her emotional. Plus, their favorite songs, their performance MVP, and does watching Hamilton make for a good first date? Kevin has stories!For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
19/01/2026 • 41:23
Get ready for a pitching good chat with "Pitch Perfect's" vocal arranger and music director. The Godfather of a cappella, Deke Sharon, joins Jenna and Kevin with a whole lotta aca-awesome behind-the-scenes scoop from the set of "Pitch Perfect!" Including why he thought the movie was going to be a straight-to-video release, the eye-popping song that didn't make the cut, the muse behind the character of Benji, and who broke down in tears during 'aca-bootcamp!' He also chats Glee and the arrangement he feels was directly stolen (or borrowed) from college a capella recordings! Plus, for anyone who is burning to join a singing group or start one, Deke is offering to help free of charge. No joke! Listen in to get his personal email address! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
15/01/2026 • 44:55
It’s an honor just to be nominated! Kevin and Jenna are back with a review of all the glitz and glamour of Hollywood’s booziest night, The Golden Globes! They dive into the new carpet layout, Nikki Glaser as a host, the real winners, show highlights, and what felt hokey and gross. Plus, they share their own experiences attending the Globes for Glee, including what happens during commercial breaks, standing on stage after winning an award, and the nominated films you should check out!For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
14/01/2026 • 19:57
It's about aca-time! Kevin and Jenna are back with a look at the musical comedy that premiered during the height of Glee madness ... Pitch Perfect! Right off the bat, Kevin admits he wasn't feeling the movie back in the day, but shares what he thinks after rewatching it! They also break down their favorite performances, thoughts on the casting choices, jokes that did not age well, Glee similarities, and the scene that gave Jenna chills! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
12/01/2026 • 37:52
Happy 2026! Kevin and Jenna are ringing in the new year with a good ol' catch-up sesh, including how they made it through the holidays, Kevin’s time on stage, the bug that is going around, and Kevin’s review of Darren Criss in Maybe Happy Ending!For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
09/01/2026 • 18:49
What better way to kick off 2026 than with a smashing good time! Jenna and Kevin are taking a look back at the TV musical series, "Smash," often seen as Glee's "competition." They have plenty to say about the pilot episode! They compare their initial impressions of the show to their rewatch, the memories the audition scenes brought up for them, their thoughts on the original songs versus the covers, and what they thought was excellent about the show and what didn't quite work for them.For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
05/01/2026 • 42:33
Jenna and Kevin are ending the year on a high note! They share what they are grateful for, the musicals they are super excited to explore for the pod, book recommendations, favorite TV shows of the year, and New Year’s resolutions! Plus, the scoop on Jenna’s brand new upcoming podcast! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
31/12/2025 • 15:45
Jenna and Kevin are getting ready to sleigh the holidays! They share their plans for the season, how Jenna is making festive magic for her kids, Kevin’s first Christmas in New York, and a tree-mendously fun game of This or That! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
24/12/2025 • 13:41
Things are getting a little spirited between Jenna and Kevin during their Glee Christmas Fantasy Draft! They’re picking their fave Glee Christmas covers, but you get to choose who has the best list! Plus, the holiday songs they can’t believe didn’t make it on Glee, the performance audio glitch you probably didn’t catch, and their quintessential favorite Christmas songs! It’s a jolly good time! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
22/12/2025 • 17:51
Jenna and Kevin are back answering some really fun and creative fan questions, like if Glee were a horror film, who would the killer be?! The performance they would re-shoot with today’s technology. Plus, Kevin reveals the big artist he said no to a collab with, Jenna’s very personal rapid-fire questions, and Kevin shares his fave movies and shows he's binging, including the one that stresses him out! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
19/12/2025 • 15:08
Get ready for an exciting behind-the-scenes look at how great music ends up on your favorite shows!Grammy & Emmy-nominated Music Supervisor Alex Patsavas joins Jenna and Kevin to chat about her journey from working in the mailroom of a talent agency straight out of college to becoming a music supervisor working on projects like The O.C., Grey’s Anatomy, the Twilight soundtracks, Bridgerton, and more! It’s a pitch-perfect chat that pulls back the curtain on what it takes to get the right song on the right show!For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
18/12/2025 • 57:06
Getting ‘gitchie gitchie’ down with Baz Luhrmann’s “Moulin Rouge.” Jenna and Kevin are back with a recap of the 2001 hit musical and get ready for rants and raves! They are in awe of the sets, the music, the cinematography, the costumes, but Kevin shares the part of the film that made him feel sick, and the scene he had to pause because it was so overwhelmingly good! They also dive into Nicole Kidman’s vocals, Ewan McGregor’s casting, and the song that should have been an Oscar contender. Plus, Kevin reveals he was in the Faith Hill “Pearl Harbor” music video but thought he was in the actual movie! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
15/12/2025 • 56:26
We’re off to see the director! "Wicked: For Good" Director Jon M. Chu joins Jenna and Kevin with great behind-the-scenes stories about Wicked, including the choice to have his leads sing live and how he pulled it off, a fowl problem on the set, the challenges of advertising a musical, and what he would be doing if he weren't a successful director! Plus, Jon on meeting Jenna and Kevin for the very first time on the set of "Glee," and an update on the "Crazy Rich Asians" musical! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
11/12/2025 • 50:46
It's time to head to Fleet Street for a bloody good time! Yes, Kevin and Jenna are reviewing the big-screen musical "Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street." They dive into the performances, their thoughts on Johnny Depp's casting, their reactions to the gory scenes, and how some of the stage magic gets lost in translation on the big screen. Plus, their favorite song from the film, Kevin's pet peeve with the vocals, and the actor they feel ate up every scene! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
08/12/2025 • 46:00
It’s Q&A Time! You have questions, and Jenna and Kevin have answers! They break down the truth behind rumors of a beef between the Glee and Smash casts, the musicals they feel would’ve made good Glee tribute episodes, the cast member Kevin says was like heaven to work with, and how you can say hi in person while he’s in NYC! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
05/12/2025 • 18:55
Get ready for a trivia match-up between two super Gleeks vs. two actual Glee actors! Jenna and Kevin face off against “Gleek of the Week” podcast host Andrew McGuire and “SLAY!!! A Queer Buffy Podcast” host Ian Alred. Will it be a fight to the finish or a total blood bath? One thing is for sure - it’s going to be fun! Plus, a few bonuses! Trivia within trivia, another game within the game, and the question that stumped them all! If you have some great Glee trivia questions you would like to submit, email us at andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod@gmail.com or DM us on Instagram!For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
04/12/2025 • 26:22
She knocks it out of the park in every medium! From the bright lights of Broadway to the small and big screen - she doesn't miss! Jenna welcomes the super-talented and super-busy actress Tracie Thoms to the pod! TV fans know her from "Cold Case" and "9-1-1," while movie fans remember her as Joanne in the film adaptation of "Rent," and as Andy's best friend in "The Devil Wears Prada" and the upcoming sequel! Tracie talks about it all, including what it was like shooting the original 'Prada' film versus the sequel, dealing with paparazzi on the set, and the blessings of being part of a long-running hit series. Plus, she shares how she got into acting, her big break with "Rent," what playing Joanne meant to her, and Jenna shares an embarrassing story that still "haunts" her to this day! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
01/12/2025 • 41:22
We're dancing through life with a wickedly good choreographer! Jenna and Kevin hang out with their pal, the exceptionally talented choreographer Christopher Scott! They discuss the joy of witnessing his journey from "Glee" to "So You Think You Can Dance" and the "Wicked" movies. They also learn the fun way he found out he was going to work on "Wicked," the emotions he felt watching Cynthia Erivo's audition, witnessing Jeff Goldblum becoming the Wizard in real time, Jonathan Bailey's take on Fiyero, which helped inspire some of the choreography, and seeing director Jon M. Chu build the world of Oz! Plus a deep dive into his creative process and inspiration for certain scenes, the dance break that didn't make it to the screen, and some fun memories from working on Glee! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
28/11/2025 • 43:33
Gobble Gobble! Kevin and Jenna are thankful they get to continue this podcast! They also share their holiday plans, their favorite foods to gobble up, what they’re making, their memories of the Macy’s Thanksgiving Parade, and a fun game of ‘would you rather.’ Happy seasons eatings! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
27/11/2025 • 13:08
It’s the sequel everyone is talking about and it dominated the box office, soaring straight to #1. Kevin and Jenna were among the many movie-goers who checked out Wicked: For Good this weekend, and their reviews are in! They’re talking what worked and what didn’t, the powerhouse performances from Cynthia, Ariana, and Jonathan Bailey, the new songs, the stage-to-screen changes, and the ending everyone is debating.Spoiler alert: Jenna & Kevin unpack it all.For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
25/11/2025 • 52:41
We are 'Dancing Through Life' with Nessarose from "Wicked" the movie musical!Marissa Bode joins Jenna to talk about "Wicked: For Good" finally hitting the big screen! She reveals some of the changes made to Nessa's character in part two, her feelings on being a part of authentic disabled casting, the close relationships she developed during the six-month production, and her reaction to the Ariana and Cynthia tears memes. Plus, Marissa also reflects on her journey to "Wicked" and the callback surprise that set the tone for her entire filming experience!For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
20/11/2025 • 36:53
This one is definitely “popular!” In honor of the upcoming release of “Wicked For Good,” Jenna and Kevin head down the yellow brick road to the big screen version of “Wicked.” They break down what they feel is the movie’s ’secret sauce,’ what had them geeking out, and the scene Kevin feels is one of the greatest moments in cinema history! Plus, the Glee connections, what it was like seeing the stage production with the original cast, and why the show was life-changing! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
17/11/2025 • 66:45
The iconic Frenchy from ‘Grease’ is on the pod!Pink Ladies royalty, Didi Conn, joins Kevin with great ‘Grease’ stories, including how she got the part of Frenchy, the role she thought was better, and the Grease 2 that never was. Plus, a preview of the film’s 50th Anniversary celebration, the personal story that makes her emotional, and a special surprise guest!For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes scoops, be sure to follow on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
13/11/2025 • 42:28
‘Bet your bottom dollar’ this is going to be a good one! Jenna and Kevin take us back to 1982, a massive year for Pop culture (Thriller, E.T., leg warmers) and the debut of “Annie,” the movie musical! They share why they feel this one is monumental, what they think of the movie now versus when they were kids, what hasn’t aged well, and the performances that still wow them. Plus, the scene they felt was over-the-top, the Glee connection, and Jenna reveals auditioning for the Broadway production of “Annie” as a kid! Don’t wait until tomorrow to check this one out! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes scoops, be sure to follow on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed! See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
10/11/2025 • 54:19
